These peanut butter cookies call for just four ingredients ... like JIF or Peter Pan. All-natural peanut butters may not have ...

The ingredient list is simple ... While I typically keep natural peanut butter stocked in my pantry, smooth peanut butter spread, such as Skippy or Jif, is actually best here.

The recipe itself hinges on just a handful of ingredients, with peanut butter and ... Our favorite is Jif Creamy, but use whatever you have. We do suggest leaving out the natural kinds, however.